So I'm thinking this could become an annual thing, Tracey the Christmas tree critic. First of all here are some disclaimers, I have only judged the decorating efforts of places I have encountered while doing my general day to day stuff (Wellington City and Karori), I am lazy and have not gone out of my way to search for these examples, also I am too lazy to take photos so if you are really interested you will have to go look for yourself.
The Worst1. Christies Flooring, KaroriOK, I understand that decorating with carpet may not be easy but, this is an example of if you don't think you can do it well don't try. Here is a description: an angel made out of carpet with a polystyrene ball for a head with tacky tinsel and a couple of sheep. I suggest that next time they keep with the Nativity theme and the sheep but forget the angel and the tinsel. Just make a cradle from some wood and fill it with straw and a baby doll.
However Christies Flooring can share this prize with most of Marsden village, here are the exceptions Cafe 162, Hopscotch and Marsden Books.
2. Wellington City Council Tree, Midland ParkThere is no excuse for faded decorations! In the past this tree has looked fine but now the red bows have faded and almost fallen off in the wind. Again I can understand, it must be difficult to design a tree to withstand Wellington's weather but, please can we have some new decorations next year.
3. Bennett's Government Bookshop, Lambton QuayBennetts mainly wins this prize because they have not lived up to expectations, they are very talented at making interesting shop displays but their tree looks like it was decorated by small children. I have seen what children can do and its not pretty.
4. Dymocks, Lambton QuayI feel alittle bad saying this because I really understand what they were trying to achieve. Less is More is usually correct, however if only they have used wider ribbon it would of looked so much better.
The Best1. Kirkcaldie and Stains, Lambton QuayI'm alittle reluctant to give Kirks this prize because I do have a few issues with this years window display. Firstly as always the Christmas shop is beautiful and every tree in the entire complex has been decorated very well. However, while executed to a very high standard the window displays have been let down by poor conceptual planning. There doesn't seem to be an overriding theme to tie them all together and the mechanical actions are too small to be seen from anywhere other than right up close to the window. Kirks this is a warning, to keep this prize next year you must try harder.
2. City GPs, Willis StreetI wasn't expecting to find brilliance here but I did, well worth a look if you can find it. Their single tree is decorated with the theme of the Maori 12 days of Christmas (A Pukeko in a Ponga Tree). For the rest of the words for this song see
http://folksong.org.nz/nzchristmas/pukeko.html3.Holiday Inn, Featherston StreetInside the lobby of the Holiday Inn there are two trees decorated exactly the same, the thing that makes them special is beautiful hanging lanterns. I have never seen decorations the same before and I really like them.
4. Farmers, Lambton QuayHaving visited Farmers in Cuba street early to look for decorations for my own tree I felt most of the decorations seem rather tacky and therefore, I am very impressed with how the tree in the Lambton Quay store looks. I am especially impressed with there ability to put pink and red together and make it look good.
Special MentionsStarbucks, all storesI love their theme! Homemade presents the perfect concept for this holiday season.
Plimmer Shoes, Lambton QuayThe best decorated shoe store. Simplicity is the key for small shops, love the baubles filled with beads.
Menswear StoresSorry girls the Menswear stores have outclassed the Women's boutiques, well done.